As suggested in a comment on the last story, it might be useful to look at top-5s in the context of races run, and have a look at the percentage of races that these drivers were able to convert into top-5s.
For the sake of brevity, I’m going to look at the four drivers mentioned in the last post.
In order of top-5 percentage:
1) David Pearson – 574 races, 301 top 5s (52%), 105 wins (18%)
2) Richard Petty – 1185 races run, 555 top 5s (47%), 200 wins (17%)
3) Bobby Allison – 717 races, 336 top 5s (46%), 85 wins (12%)
4) Jeff Gordon – 700 races run, 300 top 5s (43%), 87 wins (12%)
UPDATE – decided to add Jimmie Johnson to this list:
5) Jimmie Johnson – 410 races run, 172 top 5s (42%), 62 wins (15%)
